Skip to content
Unsolved homicide

Killing of Joseph Mayhan

Year
1991
Where
Virginia Beach, Virginia
Source
Virginia State Police
Evidence
1
What the record says

On Tuesday evening, April 2, 1991, Joseph 'Stinky' Mayhan had been seen walking in the area of Carolina Avenue and Arctic Avenue. Mr. Mayhan was found lying in a grassy area in the 700 block of Arctic Avenue. He was dressed in a dark blue sweater, off white pants and white topsider styled shoes. The cause of death was due to a gunshot wound to the chest with the manner of death a homicide.

From the Virginia State Police cold case database. Records change. The source is the authority.

Where to start

Got ten minutes? Do one of these.

What does the record establish, and what has never been explained?

  • Read the source and write down every date, place and name it gives.
  • Find the earliest news report you can and note what it says that later accounts dropped.
  • List what has never been explained. One line each.

New to this? Read the field guide. Five short lessons.

Coverage and records

What is out there.

Nobody has researched this case yet. Have the AI search the web for reporting, podcasts and videos about it.